·ÂþÂþÆäÐÞÔ¶Ù⣬ÎὫÉÏ϶øÇóË÷ - °Ù¶ÈÎÄ¿â
U6 A
To work or not to work - That is the question ´ò¹¤»¹ÊDz»´ò¹¤¡ª¡ªÕâÊǸöÎÊÌâ
There are numerous and reliable ways by which one can measure the impact of employment on student achievement, and we used several in our research. We compared the grades of students who work a great deal with those who work in limited amounts or not at all. We also contrasted workers with non-workers, on different indicators of their commitment to education. Additionally, we followed students over time as they increased or decreased their work hours, and we assessed how different patterns of employment altered school performance and engagement.
ÒªºâÁ¿¹¤×÷¾Àú¶ÔѧÉú³É¾ÍµÄÓ°ÏìÓÐÐí¶à¿É¿¿µÄ·½·¨¡£ÔÚÎÒÃǵÄÑо¿ÖУ¬ÎÒÃDzÉÓÃÁ˼¸ÖÖ·½·¨¡£ÎÒÃDZȽÏÁË´òºÜ¶à¹¤µÄѧÉúºÍ´ò¹¤Ê±¼äÓÐÏÞ»òÕ߸ù±¾²»´ò¹¤µÄѧÉúµÄѧϰ³É¼¨¡£ÎÒÃÇÒ²¶Ô±ÈÁË´ò¹¤Ñ§ÉúºÍ²»´ò¹¤Ñ§ÉúÔÚѧϰͶÈë³Ì¶È·½ÃæµÄ²»Í¬Ö¸Õ÷¡£ÁíÍ⣬ÎÒÃdz¤ÆÚ¸ú×ÙѧÉú£¬Á˽âËûÃÇÔÚ´ò¹¤Ê±¼äÔö¼Ó»ò¼õÉÙʱµÄ±íÏÖ¡£¶øÇÒ£¬ÎÒÃÇ»¹ÆÀ¹ÀÁ˲»Í¬µÄ´ò¹¤Ä£Ê½ÈçºÎ¸Ä±äѧϰ³É¼¨ºÍѧϰ²ÎÓë¶È¡£
We have simplified and classified the data and the results are clear: The stakes are high. A heavy commitment to a part-time job during the academic year, say, working 20 hours per week or more, undermines and significantly interferes with school achievement and commitment. Overall, our study offers proof that students who worked more than 20 hours weekly were not comparable to their classmates. They earned lower grades, spent less time on homework, cut class more often, and cheated more frequently. And they reported lower levels of commitment to school and more modest educational aspirations.
ÎÒÃÇ°ÑÊý¾Ý¼ÓÒÔ¼ò»¯ºÍ¹éÀ࣬µÃ³öµÄ½áÂÛºÜÃ÷È·£ºÑ§Éú´ò¹¤¸¶³öµÄ´ú¼ÛºÜ´ó¡£ÔÚѧÄêÖл¨¹ý¶à¾«Á¦¼æÖ°´ò¹¤£¬±ÈÈ磬һÖÜ´ò¹¤ 20 ¸öСʱ»ò¸ü³¤Ê±¼ä£¬»áÓ°ÏìºÍÑÏÖظÉÈÅѧϰ³É¼¨ºÍѧϰͶÈë³Ì¶È¡£×ܵÄÀ´Ëµ£¬ÎÒÃǵÄÑо¿Ö¤Ã÷£¬Ã¿ÖÜ´ò¹¤³¬¹ý 20 ¸öСʱµÄѧÉúѧϰ³É¼¨²»¼°°àÉÏÆäËûͬѧ¡£ËûÃǵķÖÊý¸üµÍ£¬»¨ÔÚ×÷ÒµÉϵÄʱ¼ä¸üÉÙ£¬ÌӿθüƵ·±£¬×÷±×¸ü³£¼û¡£¶øÇҾݷ´Ó³£¬ËûÃǵÄѧϰͶÈë³Ì¶È½ÏµÍ£¬Ñ§Ï°Ö¾ÏòÒ²²»¹»Ô¶´ó¡£
On the other hand, we also detected a different pattern. Working for approximately 10 hours per week or less seemingly does not take a consistent toll on school performance. Nevertheless, given that half of all employed seniors, about one-third of all juniors, and about one-fifth of all second-year students work above the 20-hour limit, indications are that a large number of students are at risk of compromising their school careers with their part-time jobs.
µ«ÊÇ£¬ÎÒÃÇÒ²·¢ÏÖÁËÁíÍâÒ»ÖÖ²»Í¬µÄģʽ¡£Ã¿ÖÜ´ò¹¤´óÔ¼ 10 ¸öСʱ»ò¸üÉÙµÄʱ¼ä¶Ôѧϰ³É¼¨ËƺõûÓгÖÐøµÄÓ°Ïì¡£²»¹ý£¬¼øÓÚÒ»°ëµÄ´óËÄ´ò¹¤Ñ§Éú¡¢Ô¼Èý·ÖÖ®Ò»µÄ´óÈý´ò¹¤Ñ§ÉúÒÔ¼°Ô¼Îå·ÖÖ®Ò»µÄ´ó¶þ´ò¹¤Ñ§ÉúµÄ´ò¹¤Ê±¼ä¶¼³¬¹ý 20 ¸öСʱµÄÉÏÏÞ£¬Óɴ˱íÃ÷£¬ÓкܶàѧÉúÃæÁÙÒò´ò¹¤¶øΣ¼°Ñ§ÒµµÄ·çÏÕ¡£
Whereas it is true that more disengaged students are more likely to work long hours to begin with, it appears that working makes a marginal situation worse. In other words, over time, the more students work, the less committed to school they become. When students withdraw from the labor force or cut back on their work 11
·ÂþÂþÆäÐÞÔ¶Ù⣬ÎὫÉÏ϶øÇóË÷ - °Ù¶ÈÎÄ¿â
hours, however, the results are striking: Their interest in school is generated anew. This then is good news: The negative effects of working on schooling are not permanent.
Ëä˵һ¿ªÊ¼È·ÊµÊÇѧϰÐËȤ²»´óµÄѧÉú¸üÈÝÒ׳¤Ê±¼äµØ´ò¹¤£¬µ«ÊÇ´ò¹¤¿´ÆðÀ´»áÈÃËûÃÇÔ±¾ÃãÇ¿µÄѧϰ״¿ö±äµÃ¸üÔã¡£»»ÑÔÖ®£¬Ëæ×Åʱ¼äµÄÍÆÒÆ£¬Ñ§Éú´ò¹¤Ê±¼äÔ½³¤£¬ËûÃǶÔѧϰµÄͶÈë¾ÍÔ½ÉÙ¡£µ«ÊÇ£¬µ±Ñ§ÉúÍ˳ö´ò¹¤¶ÓÎé»òÕß¼õÉÙ´ò¹¤Ê±¼äºó£¬½á¹ûÒ²ÒýÈËעĿ£ºËûÃǶÔѧϰµÄÐËȤ±»ÖØм¤·¢ÆðÀ´¡£ËùÒÔ£¬ÕâÊǸöºÃÏûÏ¢£¬¼´´ò¹¤¶ÔѧϰµÄ¸ºÃæÓ°Ïì²¢·ÇÊÇÓÀ¾ÃÐԵġ£ We uncovered numerous explanations for the undesirable effects of working on students' engagement in school. First, owing to their demanding work schedule, working students have less time to devote to school assignments. One common response to this time pressure is that they cut corners by taking easier classes, copying assignments from other students, cutting class, or refusing to do work assigned by their teachers. Over time, as these become established practices, students' commitment to school is eroded bit by bit.
ÎÒÃÇ·¢ÏÖÁË´ò¹¤¶ÔѧÉúѧϰ²ÎÓë¶È²úÉú¸ºÃæÓ°ÏìµÄºÜ¶àÖÖÔÒò¡£Ê×ÏÈ£¬ÓÉÓÚ½ôÕŵĴò¹¤Èճ̣¬´ò¹¤µÄѧÉúÓÃÀ´Íê³ÉѧУ×÷ÒµµÄʱ¼ä¾Í¼õÉÙÁË¡£ÃæÁÙÕâÑùµÄʱ¼äѹÁ¦£¬´ò¹¤Ñ§ÉúÒ»¸öÆÕ±éµÄÓ¦¸¶°ì·¨¾ÍÊÇ͵ÀÁ£¬±ÈÈçÑ¡Ôñ½ÏÈÝÒ׵Ŀγ̡¢³Ï®ÆäËûѧÉúµÄ×÷Òµ¡¢ÌӿλòÕß²»×öÀÏʦ²¼ÖõÄ×÷Òµ¡£Ê±¼äÒ»³¤£¬µ±ÕâЩ±ä³ÉÏ°ÒÔΪ³£µÄ×ö·¨ÒÔºó£¬Ñ§Éú¶ÔѧϰµÄͶÈëÒ²¾ÍÒ»µãÒ»µãµØ¼õÉÙ¡£
Second, in order to work 20 hours or more each week, many students must work evenings. Evening work interferes not only with doing homework, but with both sleep and diet. Studies show that working students get less rest and eat less healthy meals than non-working students. Burning the midnight oil makes working teenagers more tired in school. Teachers frequently complain about working students falling asleep in class. Nearly a third of the students in our study said they were frequently too tired from work to do their homework.
µÚ¶þ£¬ÎªÁËÿÖÜÄÜ´ò¹¤ 20 ¸öСʱ»ò¸ü³¤Ê±¼ä£¬Ðí¶àѧÉú±ØÐëÒªÔÚÍíÉϹ¤×÷¡£ÍíÉϹ¤×÷²»½öÓ°Ïì×ö×÷Òµ£¬¶øÇÒÓ°Ïì˯ÃߺÍÒûʳ¡£Ñо¿±íÃ÷£¬Óë²»´ò¹¤µÄѧÉúÏà±È£¬´ò¹¤Ñ§ÉúµÄÐÝϢʱ¼ä¸üÉÙ£¬ÒûʳҲ²»¹»½¡¿µ¡£°¾Ò¹Èôò¹¤µÄÇàÉÙÄêÔÚѧУʱ¸Ð¾õ¸üÆ£¾ë¡£ÀÏʦÃǾ³£±§Ô¹´ò¹¤Ñ§ÉúÔÚ¿ÎÌÃÉÏ˯¾õ¡£ÔÚÎÒÃǵĵ÷²éÖУ¬½«½üÈý·ÖÖ®Ò»µÄѧÉú˵£¬ËûÃǾ³£Òò´ò¹¤Ì«ÀÛ¶ø²»×ö×÷Òµ¡£
Third, it appears that the excitement of earning large amounts of spending money makes school seem less rewarding and interesting.
µÚÈý£¬Õõµ½ÊýÁ¿¿É¹ÛµÄÁ㻨ǮËù´øÀ´µÄÐ˷ܸÐËƺõÈÃÉÏѧÏÔµÃûÒâÒåºÍ·¦Î¶¡£
Although mind-wandering during school is characteristic of young adults, working students report significantly more of it than non-workers. Indeed, the rush from earning and spending money may be so strong that students who have a history of intensive employment, those who, for example, have been working long hours since their second year, are actually at greater risk than their classmates of dropping out before graduating. Ëä˵ÔÚѧУѧϰʱÐIJ»ÔÚÑÉÊÇÄêÇáÈ˵Äͨ²¡£¬µ«ÊǾݷ´Ó³£¬´ò¹¤µÄѧÉú±È²»´ò¹¤µÄѧÉúÔÚÕâ·½Ãæ±íÏֵøüΪÔã¸â¡£ÊÂʵÉÏ£¬×¬Ç®ºÍ»¨Ç®´øÀ´µÄ¿ì¸ÐÒ²Ðí¹ýÓÚÇ¿ÁÒ£¬ÒÔÖÁÓÚÓг¤Ê±¼ä´ò¹¤Ê·µÄѧÉú£¬±ÈÈç´Ó´ó¶þ¿ªÊ¼¾Í³¤Ê±¼ä´ò¹¤µÄѧÉú£¬Êµ¼ÊÉϱÈÆäËûͬѧÃæÁÙ¸ü´óµÄê¡Ñ§·çÏÕ¡£ Finally, working long hours can be associated with increased alcohol and drug 22
·ÂþÂþÆäÐÞÔ¶Ù⣬ÎὫÉÏ϶øÇóË÷ - °Ù¶ÈÎÄ¿â
use. Working students use drugs and alcohol about 33% more often than non-working students. Our long-term study shows that working long hours leads to increased alcohol and drug use for entertainment and recreation among working students. Teenagers with between $200 and $300 of monthly surplus income frequently have more money to spend than their peers, and often they become accustomed to spending their earnings on drugs and alcohol. According to our study, alcohol and drug use, in turn, may be linked to disengagement from school, and therefore, is likely to depress school performance. ×îºó£¬³¤Ê±¼ä´ò¹¤ÓëÒû¾ÆºÍÎü¶¾µÄÔö¶àÓйء£´ò¹¤µÄѧÉúÎü¶¾ºÍÒû¾ÆµÄ¸ÅÂʱȲ»´ò¹¤µÄѧÉúÒª¸ß³ö´óÔ¼ 33%¡£ÎÒÃǵij¤ÆÚÑо¿ÏÔʾ£¬³¤Ê±¼ä´ò¹¤µ¼Ö´ò¹¤µÄѧÉú¸ü¶àµØÒû¾ÆºÍÎü¶¾£¬ËûÃǽè´ËÀ´ÓéÀÖºÍÏûDz¡£Ã¿Ô¶àÊÕÈë 200 ÖÁ 300 ÃÀÔªµÄÇàÉÙÄêͨ³£±ÈÆäËûͬѧÓиü¶àµÄÁ㻨Ǯ£¬¶øÇÒËûÃÇÒ²³£³£Ï°¹ßÓÚ°Ñ×Ô¼º×¬À´µÄÇ®»¨ÔÚÎü¶¾ºÍÒû¾ÆÉÏ¡£ÎÒÃǵÄÑо¿±íÃ÷£¬Òû¾ÆºÍÎü¶¾ÏàÓ¦µØ¿ÉÄÜÔì³ÉѧϰÐËȤ¼õÈõ£¬Òò´ËºÜ¿ÉÄܵ¼ÖÂѧϰ³É¼¨Ï½µ¡£
To summarize, convention has long held that early employment builds character. Our findings indicate that for many students, working 20 hours or more a week can contribute to decreased school performance and increased drug and alcohol use. We know that these findings may seem controversial to many. To our own surprise, our findings make us question how long we have held on to the conventional assumptions about the great value of work in our formative years. It's time to abandon this appealing myth! We conclude that students should resolve to work no more than 10 hours per week if they want to be successful in school.
×ܶøÑÔÖ®£¬³¤ÆÚÒÔÀ´µÄ´«Í³¹ÛÄîÒ»Ö±ÈÏΪ£¬ÔçÆڵŤ×÷¾ÀúÄÜ´¸Á¶ÐÔ¸ñ¡£¶øÎÒÃǵÄÑо¿½á¹û±íÃ÷£¬¶ÔÓÚÐí¶àѧÉú¶øÑÔ£¬Ã¿ÖÜ´ò¹¤ 20 ¸öСʱ»ò¸ü¶àʱ¼ä»áµ¼ÖÂѧϰ³É¼¨µÄÏ»¬ÒÔ¼°Îü¶¾ºÍÒû¾ÆµÄÔö¶à¡£ÎÒÃÇÖªµÀÕâЩÑо¿½á¹û¿ÉÄÜÔÚÐí¶àÈË¿´À´ÊÇÓÐÕùÒéµÄ¡£ÁîÎÒÃǸе½¾ªÑȵÄÊÇ£¬ÎÒÃǵÄÑо¿½á¹û´ÙʹÎÒÃÇÖÊÒÉ£¬ÎªºÎ³¤¾ÃÒÔÀ´ÎÒÃÇÒ»Ö±¼áÊØ×ÅÄÇÖÖ´ò¹¤ÓÐÀûÓÚÎÒÃdzɳ¤µÄ´«Í³Ïë·¨¡£ÏÖÔÚÊÇÞðÆúÕâÖÖÓÕÈ˵ĴíÎó¹ÛÄîµÄʱºòÁË£¡ÎÒÃǵĽáÂÛÊÇ£ºÒªÏëѧҵ³É¹¦£¬Ñ§Éú¾ÍÓ¦¸ÃϾöÐÄ×öµ½Ã¿ÖÜ´ò¹¤²»³¬¹ý 10 ¸öСʱ¡£
33