融资意外地拯救了被遗弃的干细胞试验
———————————————————————————————— 作者: ———————————————————————————————— 日期:
?
Funding windfall rescues abandoned stem-cell trial A landmark stem-cell trial is sputtering back to life two-and-a-half years after?it was abandoned by the California
company that started it. But it now faces a
fresh set of challenges, including a field that is packed with competitors.?The trial aims to test whether cells
derived from human embryonic stem?cells can help nerves to regrow in cases
of spinal-cord injury. It was stopped
abruptly in 2011 by Geron ofNature 479, 459; 2011); thefirm
said at the time that it
wanted to focus on several?promising cancer treatments
instead. Now, a new company
— Asterias Biotherapeutics, also of Menlo Park — plans to resurrect
the trial with a US$14.3-million?grant that it received on 29 May from the
California Institute for Regenerative Medicine?(CIRM), the state’s stem-cell-funding agency. But the field has moved on since Geron
treated its first patient in 2010, and the therapy?that Asterias inherited is no longer the only?possibility for spinal-cord injury. StemCells, a biotechnology company in Newark, California, has treated 12 patients in a safety study
of a different type of stem cell, and it plans to?start a more advanced trial this year to test effectiveness. And another entrant to the?field, Neuralstem of Germantown, Maryland,
received regulatory approval in January 2013
to begin human tests of its stem-cell product.?Geron’s human trial was the first approved to?use cells derived from human embryonic stem?cells. But regulators halted it twice, once cit
ing?concerns about the purity and predictability of the cells being implanted, and again after the company reported seeing microscopic cysts in?the spinal cords of rats that had been treated in?preclinical studies. The worry was that the cysts could be teratomas — uncontrolled growths
that can form from embryonic stem cells, a
feared side effect of treatment. Geron later said?that the growths were not terato
mas, and the?US Food and Drug Administration allowed the
trial to proceed. But after injecting the cells into?five of the ten intended patients, the company
said that it had run out of money for the trial.?Geron founder Michael West and former
chief executive Thomas Okarma then formed?Asterias, which bought Geronв??s stem-cell?therap
y last year. The company plans first to?treat three patients with spinal-cord damage?in th
e neck, using a low dose of the stem cells; it will then treat different people with higher?doses to see if the therapy can restore any sensation?or function in the trunk or limbs.?The five patients previously treated by?Geron, whom Asterias continues to track, had
cord damage at chest level. On 22 May, Asterias
reported that none of those five had experienced serious side effects from the treatment or developed immune responses to it.
Researchers say that the continuation of the
former Geron trial is important because it uses?a type of cell different from the fetus-derived?ones used by StemCells and Neuralstem. Geron?sur
gically implanted embryonic stem cells that?had been coaxed in vitro to grow into immature
myelinated glial cells, which insulate nerve?fibres when mature. The other companies are?using partially differentiated cells derived from
fetal brain tissue, which might produce substances that protect surviving tissue and make?new connections in the neural circuitry.?в??Itв??s very good for the field, because we now
have multiple cell lines being tested in very similar?populations of patients, and this will help us
define what is needed to make this approach?work,в?? says Martin Marsala, a neuroscientist
the University of California, San Diego,
whose work has shown that Neuralstem’s cells
can develop into working neurons and restore?movement to rats with cord injuries in the neck.?Still, some in the field question whether?stem cells are a good candidate for treating?paralysis. Spinal trauma can destroy a range
of cells; it can be difficult to access the injury?site; and damage can be very severe. Treating paralysis “may be asking a lot more of
the cells than they are capable of biologically”, says Robert Lanza, chief scientific?officer at Advanced Cell Technology in Marlborough,?Massachusetts, which is now testing?embryo-derived stem cells in tw
o eye diseases.?Lanza says that his company opted not to?buy Geron’s stem-cell therapy in part because?the treatment did not seem effective enough
in animal models. Some of the scientists who?reviewed Asterias’s grant proposal to the?CIRM also expressed concern about the treatment’s?effectiveness in animals. “It would be
fantastic if [the cells] work, but I think it would
also be wise not to set expectations too high,” says Lanza.?Marsala counters that the cells do not have
to heal the spinal cord completely to improve people’s lives. He notes that simply replacing injured or dead cells with healthy ones migh
t?prevent the damage from spreading. StemCells?has reported that four people in its studies have?recovered some sensation; two previously had
no feeling in their lower limbs and another two?had some but were able to feel more after the?cell transplant. Marsala sees this as a sign that the therapy is working. “Nobody is claiming
that you are going to see complete recovery in?these patients,” he says.?Christopher Scott, an ethicist at Stanford?University in California, say